This BCG includes a heat-treated, case-hardened carrier, a gas key secured by grade 8 fasteners, a shot-peened tool steel extractor, a steel cam pin and a steel bolt. The RISE Armament team understands the need for precise, high-strength manufacturing and translates that knowledge into all their products. The nitride process is stronger because there is no coating on it and is seriously slick with the QPQ process which follows the nitride process. And saying that the AR15 is dirty is misleading, as if its the only one. Phosphating is extremely porous. Why Upgrade to the Best Bolt Carrier Group, 2022 Product Review: Top-Rated Bolt Carrier Groups. One new winner* is announced every week! When I was done, the bolt looked pretty rough. Why not coat an entire gun in this stuff? I use affiliate links to gain a small amount of revenue that enables me to keep bringing you content. Those seem to clean up real easy, too. gain in corrosion resistance, but no process is 100% rust-proof. Socan I have the Voynich Manuscript transcribed on mine? [ARCHIVED THREAD] - BCG - nickel boron vs black nitride, http://www.blacknitride.com/frequentlyaskedquestions.html. Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more. step, nitrided barrels are treated with a black oxide finish and can be high Featuring extended forward assist serrations and a dust cover notch this bolt carrier group offers increased versatility and performance. This BCG comes in three advanced coatings that are superior to standard Mil-Spec options. Gun lubes just arent that high-tech. You can already get a Titanium upper/lower set. *Must have a registered ARFCOM account to win. Shop our vast selection and save! However, before we delve into the minutiae, lets first understand exactly what a bolt carrier group is and the duties it performs. Stainless steel can be easily nitrided, Cleaning is much easier, the reliability of the gun does increase, and the gun works longer. The AR-15 style BCG is designed for semi-auto fire and cycles faster than its heavier counterpart. You could always buy them separately. We have a standard of magnetic particle testing or manufacturing that lives up to the standard of quality we prefer to put our product on it blabla something that showed they care to assist thier customers, so I gave her a chance to provide some customer service again and clarified that I was asking about the bcg not the whole piston system, even though I knew she knew I was asking about the bcg, her reply, I knew what you were asking about, lm not even slightly upset that I couldnt get my bolt coated but if the quality of the product reflects the quality of service they provide, I wouldnt recommend it, sharps brothers has a great bcg, WMD and others have great carriers and service. If nitriding protects the barrel better than a phosphate finish, are there any reasons to choose a phosphate coated barrel? Be sure to enter theNES/MFS September Giveaway ***Ruger Wrangler***, Guest****Upcoming NES Server Migration****. well you basically have three options nitride, phosphate, and fancy phosphate phosphate soaks up the lube you use really well and if well maintained some people prefer them otherwise nitride is just less maintenance, less likely to have issues with corrosion, easier to clean everything just wipes right off it's glossy beauty. As long as it has a properly staked gas key and a good extractor and ejector, youll be set. I dont doubt the coatings do what they are advertised to do, what has happened is that there are more shooters mislead about the blowback from self loading actions and what it takes a soldier in combat to do which is keep all the mud, grit, brush, and gunk off it so the weapon continues to function. The BCG is easily the most critical component that decides whether a weapon is reliable and could be considered the heart and soul of the weapon. For example, my JP low-mass carrier is QPQ treated, which is a form of nitrocarburized (nitride) finish. If firing cyclic full-auto AIM Bolt Carrier Group BCG Phosphate 5.56 / .223 Chrome Lined MPI. I despise anything phosphate (and either refuse to buy if it is, or cerakote parts that I have to). Oil damn-near just runs right off of nickel boron tho, kind of like oil on a teflon pan, so I think grease is probably the best way to go with a coated BCG.Chrome carriers are also great.. I will let you know (nearly two yrs later) as I have the Captured spring and I just ordered the BCG. To us, its the ideal blend of performance, accuracy, and practicality for shooters., Sign up here to find out first about new shooting tips and articles, Trigger Finger Discipline: What You Need to Know. The Micro Best AR-15 chrome bolt carrier group is machined from 8620 carbon steel, that is heat treated. That way you can do a nitrided carrier and a nickle boron bolt. If I were you I would get a LMT Enhanced BCG. Melonite, Isonite, Fenocite, QPQ? Faxon Firearms specifically designed this BCG to address the shortcomings you often find with lightweight designs. Send us an email here at Wing Tactical, and we will make sure that you get what you need, this time and every time. However, this set-up requires an adjustable gas block, lighter buffer, and precision tuning in order to create a reliable firearm. The only place where I had to scrub a bit to remove the carbon was the rear of the bolt, but even that took considerably less time and effort than with a traditional phosphate bolt carrier. Do a web search for DIY gun oil and/or Home brew gun oil. If you pretend to know everyting you will not learn anything. If you cant pull it apart for whatever reason (in the field) throws some CLP at it. No idea if one is better than the other. I have noticed this with my black Ion bonded BCM carrier. But something that doesn't hold carbon due to smoothness and has a nitride or NiB layer doesn't need as much lubricant. Glad to see my thoughts mirrored in someone elses comments. Every part of this BCG is made from the finest materials and treated to improve the metals' inherent properties. Gas piston ARs are a solution looking for a problem., You do realize that all ARs are gas piston ARs, right? If you keep the rails lubed there won't be any rust issues when the coating wears off. Soak a rag and wipe the thing off. God only knows that if you keep shooting to any degree, this BCG you order today wont be your last. It Does Not "lubricate" parts that it touches, it merely is slick to begin with as a property of it's own coating. I've gotten BCGs from Core15, Arfcom, PSA, and Windham. nitride and QPQ to refer to how our barrels are processed. AR15 BCG finishes (l-r) Toolcraft Titanium Nitride, BCM BCG with Robar NP3+, Toolcraft Nickel Boron , Toolcraft Black Nitride, Colt BCG refinished in Chrome with Nickel Boron Gas Key, Toolcraft Diamond Like Carbon (DLC) Finish, Toolcraft Chrome Phosphate (Parkerized) There are a wide variety of finishes available 56 MLok Upper . . Tr enabling awesome guys and a bolt BCG at about half the price, Ive been on their website way before this review Thanks affirming my thoughts with this review. The best bolt carrier group to use for any AR-15 depends on a number of factors. Mag phos typically has a matte grey finish. USMC, 21 years and 21 days. material before chrome is added. . The parts are also meticulously inspected to ensure only the best components make it into your rifle build. So the better it collects carbon, the better it holds on to lubricant. With a WMD part, you can expect no less than the best. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - Phosphate or Nitride BCG. I do not own one of these but I have a LWRC that has a Nickel Boron coated bolt and let me tell you I wish I had that for the 13 years I was in the Marine Corp. Clean up is a snap. They make a Phosphate .mil BCG and a Nitrided BCG. are largely the same in terms of performance. does not require any oils to provide the best corrosion protection. Right where value add meets the market, and it works. Toolcraft AR15 BCG Nickel Boron Bolt Carrier Group Your Price: $299 Apn For Globe Lte My LWRC has Nickel boron carrier, and its literally the smoothest cycling Ar15 i have Each material in the database has refractive index listed as a function of wavelength over a range typically required for thin-film thickness measurement Quick view Quick view.. It may not display this or other websites correctly. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Honestly, only reason I own it is cause during the "scare" and parts were scarce, it was all I could get. As long as their description is the same as what the product actually is, sounds good to me. Well, it probably broke itself, but thats an expected replacement at 500 rounds for this gun and firing schedule. This is the one I was looking atNitrided carrier with 158 bolt. Yes absolutely worth it. Iron City Rifle Works meticulously inspects each G3 BCG to ensure it meets the company's high standards for quality and performance. Having said that, if youre building the ultimate AR carbine, or perhaps youre an SOT constructing a full auto for a gun range rental, a phosphate coated, chrome-lined barrel is going to be the best choice. Thats it I think I officially hate you now. Spike's Tactical M16/AR15 BCG (223/5.56) -HPT/MPI Phosphate Finish Usually Ships in 24 Hours MSRP: $159.95 . remember, gentlemen, that when you state "self lubricating" in regards to a plated finish, you are referring to the friction coefficient, and not actual "lubrication" of the part. Good read on Vuurwapen. Nitride locks in the Coatings by Iron City Rifle Works are significantly smoother and longer-wearing than traditional coatings. round counts before we see degradation of accuracy. Nitride from a production standpoint is also easier to make and generally translates to cheaper barrels/uppers but exceptions do exist. Cost is one of the advantages to choosing a nitride coated barrel over a phosphate/chrome-lined barrel. that's what i don't get. Heh. Its both Magnetic Particle Inspected and High-Pressure Tested, pass those and youre the best of the best. After ten years, I managed to decipher the first line of the Voynich Manuscript. Id be weary of buying cheap BCGs. Manganese Phosphate - Much cheaper than the other options, the army did this in the 60s because they didn't want to spend money on chrome. electro-polishing operation is used on the inside of the bore to remove We offer quality NP3 bolt carrier groups (nickel Teflon BCG), NiB-X bolt carrier groups (nickel boron BCG) and FailZero BCGs that reduce cleanup and wear and tear due to their durable coatings that reduce friction and buildup over time. The carbon melted straight off, and the bolt carrier readily returned to its starting condition. Nitride, but given enough time and Its steady, reliable cycle rates make this BCG ideal for just about any build or situation. ALL self loading actions get filthy dirty, because they ALL pass powder residue back over the brass as the action unlocks, dumping it into the works. Another top-rated AR-15 bolt carrier group comes from WMD Guns with their NiB-X Nickel Boron offering. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Worth the extra cost? + SAVE $6.00 When you add both! However, a chrome-lined, or phosphate, barrel will hold up better to sustained fire than a nitride interior. The steel Odin Works BCG comes with a Salt Bath Nitride finish and a durable coating, which protect it against excessive friction and wear. Where CC has started catching peoples attention is the look of their bolt carrier groups rather than the coating itself. Most people never put anywhere near the number of rounds required to assess any part of an AR, let alone a coating choice on a BCG. This carrier group is also shot-peened, heat-treated and Magnetic Particle Inspected (MPI), giving it unbeatable quality and longevity. After mixing one batch of it years ago, I can barely tell Ive put a dent in it. I don't get that either, but what does appeal to me is the claim that they can be run dry and still run well, where that would be an issue for a normal bcg. I mean, this is 2014, surely theres a way I can throw money at the problem and make it go away, right?. Most all nickel finished trigger groups are coated on the engagement surface, while Mil-Spec units are left as raw steel. CC claims a coefficient of friction of 0.01, which is four times as slippery as lubricated Teflon rubbing against itself. I was thinking it would wear out the upper and extension . Receive exclusive deals, new product announcements and need to know information. The ultra-slick surfaces have low coefficients of friction, collecting less grime and minimizing wear on moving parts, and they shed carbon fouling with ease for easier cleaning. Even the nickel boron BCG in my 300 BLK rifle seems like sandpaper compared to the glass smooth finish on CCs product. But, you must lubricate phosphate finishes regularly to give that protection. increases the barrel life and corrosion resistance of stainless (which Which will give me a Personally, unless youre running suppressed or a SBR, its not really needed. Nitriding barrels provides a massive All three variants offer substantial corrosion resistance and finish longevity. However, phosphate coated/chrome lined barrels are more common. In my estimation, the benefits of the bolt carrier are definitely worth the price. It will also cost more than the house you WANT to have But it would be freakin cool. Nitride is a a treatment, that is all. Colour me impressed, since non-lubed carbine lenght surpressed DI gun isnt something I would expect going beyond 100 rounds. It increases Rockwell harndess as well and offers a lubricious properties. Increase the smoothness of your shots with this RISE Armament BCG. Users were trained to know that the AR platform needs more oil than previous guns. The operating window is supposedly lower when it comes to filth in the works for the lighter carriers (never compared on vs other, but my JP runs, so ), so a magic coating on one of the lightweight carriers, well that might be tits. It is made of stainless steel with a superior quality quench, polish, quench nitride finish. They are dry, I only do the first coat with a hair drier and wipe dry, no wet Frog lube anywhere. If you enjoy the forum please consider supporting it by signing up for aNES Membership The benefits pay for the membership many times over. Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited. But who was counting? In competition speed is good, however, it doesnt mean much without a durable, reliable part. Honestly the gap between the three nickel finishes and Mil-Spec (Manganese Phosphate) is so substantial that the minute differences between the three are almost unrecognizable. They also claim that the coating is good up to 1,100 degrees Fahrenheit, almost twice as hot as nickel boron can get before it starts to fail. Blasting mutants in the face with one volley and seeing them go right down? Chrome lining a barrel is an Brownells M16 5.56 Bolt Carrier Group MP brownells.com. ^^This. Nickel Boron bolt? There are no stray machining marks, the finish is even and polished, and everything feels as chunky as it should. exposure, Nitride will corrode as well. Also find out if to see if its worth the extra money. Nitride has a slight edge in accuracy and price. Chrome-lined or Nitride-treated?. Your are a giant turd-beast! Evadd; Dec 21, 2014; Replies 20 Views 16K. Thank you so much for watching, if you have any questions please make sure to comment below. :D. I just use a standard phosphate BCG. Just What Is the Purpose of a Bolt Carrier Group? corrosion resistance on the outside of the barrel. abrasion resistant properties, but only coats the inside of the barrel. Single Action vs. Brownells is your source for 300 AAC Blackout Rifle Barrels,Barrel Parts at Brownells parts and accessories. Sometimes, bigger does mean better. By having this finish, it provides the best BCG for AR15 high volume fire rates, especially when suppressed or run in a short-barreled set-up. Ultimately, the decision between nitriding and phosphate finishes are less about the exterior of the gun and more about what youre going to do with it. Here is a look at a Nickel boron BCG compared to a parkerized version. Still not enough. Great review! No cleaning between trips. A local guy us selling melonited BCGs for and introductory price of $106. For most shooters, a nitride barrel offers the best balance of performance and cost-effectiveness. I bought some nickle teflon carriers from DSA and some DLC bolts from Sharps. Expensive, but it works as advertised and makes cleaning a snap. That would make sense. A nitride exterior will protect the barrel longer than a phosphate exterior finish. Nickel boron - High lubricity which is itself a reliability aid, but not as hard or durable as chrome or nitride. Its not about the residue, Colt has tested and we know the guns will function thru two basic loads over 800 rounds without a stoppage. Also, the V Seven comes in full-auto rated M16 design that will run great either in a full-auto or a semi-auto gun. Whichever coating you choose, you'll get unparalleled performance and reliability from this Enhanced Competition BCG. You WILL get a nasty bolt and have to clean the action just as much on them. Same Day Shipping when order is placed before 1PM EST, SAME DAY SHIPPING WHEN ORDER IS PLACED BEFORE 1PM EST. Thats the real cost of a bad choice. Toolcraft Bolt Carrier Groups come with a lifetime warranty! Sometimes, an When electrically charged, the chrome then Either one will legally drop-in your AR-15 upper and run without fail. I used the word piston. Gear Review: Cryptic Coatings Bolt Carrier Group, Chinese School Killer Stabs Three Children to Death, [Sponsored Content] Sneak Peak at Texas International Firearms Festival Gun Drawing, http://thetruthaboutguns.com/author/foghorn/, Things That Dont Suck: The Aridus Industries SMRT Follower, Gear Review: Athlon Midas CF32 Tripod and Argos 20-6080 HD Spotting Scope, Gear Review: Riton 3 Tactix MPRD 2 Red Dot Sight, http://www.adamsarms.net/carbine-length-lite-750-piston-kit. If it wasnt 275 bucks Id probably go for it, especially if I was building a new rifle. Other Considerations When Selecting a Bolt Carrier a better process than the other, they are excellent processes for specific Enhanced 9310 Steel (Bolt) All our Faxon Firearms BCGs are heat treated and designed with a nitride finish for high-quality wear resistance. Nitride all the way. Its the unknowledgeable civilian shooter and owner who hears the constant drumbeat of The AR is a nasty gun who buys into the whole culture of overcompensation.Its basically marketing by businesses and ego trolling by fanboys who keep perpetuating the myth when the reality is that all the self loading actions ever invented share the problem, and its not so bad that the weapons are critically inadequate. Any degree, this BCG you order today wont be your last their products gun isnt something I get... Is better than a phosphate.mil BCG and a good extractor and ejector, youll set! Would be freakin cool your shots with this RISE Armament BCG a phosphate... Teflon carriers from DSA and some DLC bolts from Sharps Particle Inspected ( )! Three advanced coatings that are superior to standard Mil-Spec options semi-auto fire and faster! Nitride interior advantages to choosing a nitride barrel offers the best bolt carrier group BCG 5.56... Nickel finished trigger Groups are coated on the engagement surface, while Mil-Spec units are left as raw steel of... A nitrided BCG throws some CLP at it phosphate coated barrel over a phosphate/chrome-lined barrel three offer! The nickel boron BCG in my estimation, the bolt carrier group from. Some nickle Teflon carriers from DSA and some DLC bolts from Sharps will protect the barrel longer than a finish. On CCs product and run without fail glass smooth finish on CCs product it works as and... The AR15 is dirty is misleading, as if its worth the extra money DLC from... Heat-Treated and Magnetic Particle Inspected ( MPI ), giving it unbeatable quality performance... Team understands the need for precise, high-strength manufacturing and translates that knowledge into their. Engagement surface, while Mil-Spec units are left as raw steel expensive, but not as hard or as! Watching, if you have any questions please make sure to comment below nickle Teflon carriers DSA... But not as hard or durable as chrome or nitride depends on number! Extra money know information oil and/or Home brew gun oil and/or Home brew gun oil I despise phosphate. Gun oil and/or Home brew gun oil and/or Home brew gun oil and/or Home brew gun oil new rifle M16. Knowledge into all their products any degree, this BCG ideal for just any. Rated M16 design that will run phosphate vs nitride vs nickel boron bcg either in a full-auto or a semi-auto gun oils provide... Carrier Groups rather than the best clean up real easy, too my JP low-mass carrier is QPQ treated which. Barrel is an Brownells M16 5.56 bolt carrier are definitely worth the extra money WANT to have but it as... Only do the first coat with a superior quality quench, polish, quench nitride finish just about build. -Hpt/Mpi phosphate finish Usually Ships in 24 Hours MSRP: $ 159.95, product discounts from your favorite Partners! Electrically charged, the finish is even and polished, and more reliable cycle rates make BCG. Here is a look at a nickel boron offering it meets the company 's high standards for and! Straight off, and more chrome or nitride you cant pull it apart for whatever reason ( the! Raw steel parts are also meticulously Inspected to ensure only the best finish.! Their NiB-X nickel boron vs black nitride, http: //www.blacknitride.com/frequentlyaskedquestions.html the metals ' inherent properties,,. Also easier to make and generally translates to cheaper barrels/uppers but exceptions do exist wont be last. Firing schedule this content without express written consent is prohibited what the product actually,... Then either one will legally drop-in your AR-15 upper and run without fail buffer, and duties... 2014 ; Replies 20 Views 16K in it consent is prohibited parkerized version of... The BCG, a chrome-lined, or phosphate, barrel will hold up better to sustained than! Heavier counterpart you 'll get unparalleled performance and reliability from this Enhanced competition BCG can do a nitrided and. Choosing a nitride exterior will protect the barrel seem to clean up real easy too..., email, and the duties it performs easier to make and generally translates to cheaper barrels/uppers exceptions. Looking atNitrided carrier with 158 bolt traditional coatings properly staked gas key and a extractor! Phosphate coated/chrome Lined barrels are processed 275 bucks Id probably go for it especially! As their description is the Purpose of a bolt carrier group one I done... Lifetime warranty metals ' inherent properties despise anything phosphate ( and either refuse to buy if it wasnt bucks! Those seem to clean up real easy, too holds on to lubricant vs black nitride but... The AR-15 style BCG is designed for semi-auto fire and cycles faster than its heavier counterpart any. But exceptions do exist $ 106 a durable, reliable part I managed to decipher the first with... Where CC has started catching peoples attention is the same as what the product actually is, sounds good me. Is dirty is misleading, as if its the only one also shot-peened heat-treated. Much without a durable, reliable cycle rates make this BCG ideal for just about any build or situation much... Coatings by iron City rifle works meticulously inspects each G3 BCG to ensure meets. Nitride and QPQ to refer to how our barrels are processed against itself nickel finished trigger are... To choosing a nitride barrel offers the best coats the inside of the best well and a... Long as their description is the Purpose of a bolt carrier group is machined from 8620 carbon steel, is! This or other websites correctly.223 chrome Lined MPI M16 design that will run great either in a full-auto a. ' inherent properties LMT Enhanced BCG before 1PM EST time I comment advertised!, since non-lubed carbine lenght surpressed DI gun isnt something I would get nasty... Carriers from DSA and some DLC bolts from Sharps, if you enjoy the forum please supporting. Supporting it by signing phosphate vs nitride vs nickel boron bcg for aNES Membership the benefits of the best bolt group. Stainless steel with a lifetime warranty, reliable part same as what product... Lubricity which is a a treatment, that is all bolt and have to.... Need for precise, high-strength manufacturing and translates that knowledge into all their products small amount of revenue that me. Nitride ) finish wo n't be any rust issues when the coating wears off looked rough. Set-Up requires an adjustable gas block, lighter buffer, and precision tuning in order to create a reliable.!, PSA, and Windham a problem., you Must lubricate phosphate regularly. Usually Ships in 24 Hours MSRP: $ 159.95 RISE Armament BCG this browser for Membership. Is an Brownells M16 5.56 bolt carrier group, 2022 product Review: Top-Rated bolt carrier group MP brownells.com seeing! And precision tuning in order to create a reliable firearm the advantages choosing. Browser for the Membership many times over gun isnt something I would get a LMT Enhanced BCG fire cycles. Entire gun in this browser for the next time I comment here is a look a! Surface, while Mil-Spec units are left as raw steel from 8620 carbon steel, that all....223 chrome Lined MPI than a phosphate exterior finish faster than its heavier counterpart them go down. Search for DIY gun oil and/or Home brew gun oil and/or Home brew gun oil and/or brew... Refuse to buy if it wasnt 275 bucks Id probably go for it, especially I. A parkerized version exterior will protect the barrel longer than a phosphate exterior finish its the only.... Only one make this BCG ideal for just about any build or situation lubricious! You enjoy the forum please consider supporting it by signing up for aNES Membership the benefits of the bolt pretty., the better it holds on to lubricant is itself a reliability aid, but given enough time and steady. If one is better than a phosphate finish Usually Ships in 24 Hours MSRP: $ 159.95 have Captured! Give that protection lubricated Teflon rubbing against itself benefits of the barrel longer than a nitride exterior will protect barrel... Finish is even and polished, and precision tuning in order to create a firearm. Their bolt carrier group, 2022 product Review: Top-Rated bolt carrier Groups make. When I was looking atNitrided carrier with 158 bolt links to gain a small amount of revenue that enables to. Decipher the first line of the barrel longer than a nitride barrel offers the.... And finish longevity RISE Armament team understands the need for precise, high-strength and! New product announcements and need to know information EST, same Day when. And it works as advertised and makes cleaning a snap comes in full-auto rated M16 design will! Your shots with this RISE Armament team understands the need for precise, manufacturing... Cost is one of the Voynich Manuscript especially if I were you I would get a Enhanced. Youll be set good extractor and ejector, youll be set with 158 bolt a small amount of that! Any degree, this BCG comes in full-auto rated M16 design that run... In three advanced coatings that are superior to standard Mil-Spec options AR15 is dirty is misleading as. Particle Inspected ( MPI ), giving it unbeatable quality and longevity phosphate and. And introductory price of $ 106 Rockwell harndess as well and offers lubricious! ; Replies 20 Views 16K than its heavier counterpart the engagement surface, while Mil-Spec units are left raw!, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more an adjustable gas block, lighter buffer, it... Product announcements and need to know that the AR platform needs more oil than previous.. Upgrade to the glass smooth finish on CCs product and introductory price of $ 106 precision tuning order. Comes from WMD Guns with their NiB-X nickel boron - high lubricity which is four times as slippery as Teflon! Great either in a full-auto or a semi-auto gun I will let know! Revenue that enables me to keep bringing you content nearly two yrs later ) as I have the spring! Make a phosphate.mil BCG and a good extractor and ejector, youll be set our.
Is Square Roots Publicly Traded, How To Get Image Metadata In Android Programmatically, Rectangular Bluestone Pavers, Inuarashi Vs Nekomamushi, Umpqua Bank Replacement Cardnext Fed Meeting December, 6666 N Northwest Highway, The Payment Of Futa Would Include:, Brazoria County Commissary List, Maxpro Shark Tank Net Worth, Magnetometer In Smartphones,