The only way families put food on their tables is with whatever they can farm or fish themselves, but they say their natural resources are in danger as more and more boats full of people arrive on their shores to pick their opihi and dive in their waters. Unlike most residents of the state, the Robinsons speak fluent Hawaiian. In a world filled with change, Niihau is an island of stability. She increased the offer to $10,000. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Yes, way, and I do not know the Robinsons. Until recently, the school only went to the eighth grade and was taught mainly from the Bible, because of a lack of textbooks. Niihau, about 18 miles northwest of Kauai, is the "Forbidden Island." "It would be a great thing for this island, except that we can't transport that power anywhere, so that becomes a problem," Robinson explains. And our family has continued that. We don't want to do high-impact tourism like Waikiki and all the hotels because that would destroy what is here.". The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". The bulk of Niihau is restricted to its 70 full-time residents and their families or to those who received a coveted invitation from the family who has owned the 69-square-mile island since 1864. Age, Biography and Wiki. discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. The island has had a few uninvited visitors, however. Ilei Beniamina, formerly of Niihau, says the Robinsons are sincere about preserving Niihau. Why is Niihau closed to the public in Hawaii? Today, Keith and Bruce Robinson, descendants of the Sinclairs, . Five of us gathered at Niihau Helicopters offices on the neighboring island of Kauai in the little town of Kaumakani. "It's a money-losing venture, but they feel an obligation to the people. Or how on the other. "I would never have left voluntarily. In a plea to state lawmakers to help protect the island, Bruce Robinson stated that "over a hundred years ago, a king asked our family to take care of the people. Your email address will not be published. Can you drive a forklift if you have been banned from driving? ", Robinson says, "The natives knew that the seals took so much food that they felt it endangered their existence, so they killed all the seals. SAHRC means the South African Human Rights Commission. "It was the best thing that ever happened to me," he says. Niihau, Hawaiis Forbidden Island. Just 17 miles from the coastline of Kauai, Hawaii boasts a historic restricted area: the small, 70-square-mile island of Niihau, also known as the Forbidden Island.. Robinson and his brother Bruce own the approximately 70-square-mile (180 km 2) island of Niihau in the Hawaiian island chain, which has been in the private possession of their family since their great-great-grandmother Elizabeth McHutchinson Sinclair (1800-1892) purchased it from King Kamehameha V for US$ 10,000 in gold. gallons of water a day to the pond, will be restored to working condition, Near the mauka point of the fishpond, the family, built a pumphouse to suck water from the pond to irrigate nearby, Archaeological surveys and other investigations put the age of the, fishpond at about 1,000 years. Two companies offer boat and snorkel tours to Lehua Island, Holo Holo Charters and Blue Dolphin Charters. (The police don't patrol Niihau, unless the Robinsons request them to do so. Tell locals in Hawaii that you're going to the island of Niihau, and they invariably exclaim, "No way! " The island is also a critical habitat for the endangered olulu plant and the Pritchardia aylmer-Robinson (named for the Robinson family), the only palm species endemic to Niihau. We're asking for all the help we can get to stop it," Robinson said. "On Niihau," she says, "the rocks are in about the same place they were when I was a child.". Crosswalk means that part of a roadway at an intersection included within the connections of the. Yes. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. We kept a respectful distance it is illegal to get too close and certainly illegal to harass a monk seal but the seal rolled and batted her eyes, as curious about us as we were about her. Access to Niihau is tightly restricted by its owners, brothers Bruce and Keith Robinson, whose ancestor paid a Hawaiian king $10,000 for it in 1864. . To date, scientists have known very little about the monk seals of Niihau. "Hawaiian Monk Seals." As a fully grown adult, she might weigh as much as 600 pounds, and if no oceangoing or human predators get to her, she and her 1,200 remaining kin, once hunted almost to extinction, could live as long as 30 years. Read more. English director and Academy Award-nominated screenwriter for the 1984 film The Killing Fields. "Every house has its own water system. The 72-square-mile Niihau is everything the major Hawaiian islands Oahu, Maui, the Big Island and its neighbor Kauai are not. 1941) Bruce Robinson: Read more about this topic: Niihau. How did Niihau become the Forbidden Island? Robinson's hope for the future includes continuing limited, low-impact tourism as a means of supporting the economy of Niihau, and to continue a working relationship with the U.S. Navy that began in 1924 and now provides about 80 percent of the island's income. whos talking, dates back to 200 B.C. Francis W. Sinclair (1797-1846) Elizabeth McHutchison (1800-1892) Charles B. Robinson: Helen Sinclair: Jane Sinclair (d. 1916) Thomas Gay . Ni'ihau residents plea with lawmakers for "no fishing" zone, Missing work furlough inmate voluntarily returns to OCCC, Man critically injured in stabbing at Oahu beach park, 'The Other Side of Paradise' with Lynn Kawano, KHNLPUBLICFILE@HAWAIINEWSNOW.COM (808) 847-3246, KGMBPUBLICFILE@HAWAIINEWSNOW.COM (808) 847-3246, KFVEPUBLICFILE@HAWAIINEWSNOW.COM (808) 847-3246, KSIXPUBLICFILE@HAWAIINEWSNOW.COM (808) 847-3246, KOGGPUBLICFILE@HAWAIINEWSNOW.COM (808) 847-3246. It's an open, empty beach.". The shoreline was covered with smooth lava that formed tide pools, brimming with sea life, including monk seals, an endangered species. But pure? Including humans. It's close, it's always there. Bruce Robinson, who runs the Niihau ranch . As pretty as they are, they taste a heck of a lot better, Rosendal said. With 363,000 acres, Kamehameha Schools is the biggest landowner. Today the island is managed by Robinson brothers, Bruce and Keith Robinson who are descendants family members of Elizabeth Sinclair. So Sinclair passed on other parcels of land she had considered on Oahu and offered King Kamehameha IV $6,000 for the island. The 72-square-mile Niihau is everything the major Hawaiian islands Oahu, Maui, the Big Island and its neighbor Kauai are not. 3 What Hawaiian island is privately owned? The Robinson Family owns 101,000 acres in Niihau and Kauai, with the majority being located on the Garden Island. A back-to-nature theme is planned, as, the resort would not have paved vehicular roads crisscrossing it, he, It will remain, as it has nearly always been, a place where, walking will be encouraged as the main mode of transportation, Ezer, When the family lived at Kapalawai full-time, they were, self-sufficient, with horses, cows, goats, pigs, gardens, fruit trees and other, Still today, employee break time is often heralded by. "What are they selling? So, we've had to learn how to adapt and live together, as we have with other animal species who come here to the Islands. A bar, two restaurants, three swimming pools, sports courts on the beach and near the home, a sewage, treatment plant and other amenities would comprise a seven-day-a-week, The bar like the meeting rooms, administrative offices and, museum to be located in the mansion still may close Sundays, in deference to, The estimated price tag for restoring the main home alone, is $1 million, a figure thought too low by some among those touring the, The parcel is blessed, Ezer said, with much mature landscaping, in place, including fruit-bearing trees. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. A group of Niihau youngsters on Kauai expressed hopes to visit Disneyland and Hollywood, but all said they want to live on Niihau. Apart from exclusive tours, this living time capsule is closed to the public. It has been privately owned since 1864, when Elizabeth Sinclair bought it from King Kamehameha V. Her descendants, the Robinsons (brothers Bruce and Keith), continue to own it. Today, Keith and Bruce Robinson, descendants of the Sinclairs, are the sole owners of the island and are committed to its preservation and its proud Hawaiian heritage. Robinson's ranch manager and another young Niihauan were introduced to the crew, and then all joined in a bumpy ride in Robinson's doorless, roofless, windshield-less, red-dirt-encrusted truck -- one of the few vehicles on the island -- to go see the seals. "We're pretty much the western-most side of the day, so to speak," Faye says. are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. Both snorkel tours combine Niihau with Kauai's Na Pali Coast and range from $250 to $285 per person for a seven-hour excursion. Although they are technically an invasive species, these boar and sheep represent a vital food source for the islands residents; however, as the full-time population of humans continues to fluctuate, the animals numbers have gotten out of control. along with many curious residents who joined the state Land Use Commission for, trip to begin a two-day public hearing that was scheduled to conclude todayis, considering a petition to change the state designation of the property from, agriculture to urban to allow a 250-cabin resort, with the mansion and an. They dont have running water, and electricity is produced by the sun or by a generator. The eland bounded with the grace of a running back headed for a touchdown. True Location of Hawaii Politically speaking it is part of the North American continent because it is a state of the US but if the rules of proximity are observed then Hawaii is more of Oceania than North American. Totally bilingual, some working on three languages. "And it worked. Chef Ethan Stowell buys a historic Seattle dive bar, Nationally acclaimed Orcas Island restaurant to reopen in new space, After 31 years in Redmond, Vertical World climbing gym has unclear future as lease ends, An urban oasis and a gem of a taco truck are some of SeaTac's hidden surprises, 8 more Seattle-area restaurant closures but 3 reopenings, too. Niihau's dimensions are 6.2 miles by 18.6 miles (10 km 30 km). Kauai steals all the rain, Rosendal explained. Niihau is located about 18 miles (29 km) west of Kauai, and the tiny, uninhabited island of Lehua lies 0.7 miles (0.61 nmi; 1.1 km) north of Niihau. But for Ni'ihau, the Hawaiian language may well have perished into extinction. We're dedicatingour July featuresto the worlds most beautiful and unique beaches and islands. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. Niihau, about 18 miles northwest of Kauai, is the Forbidden Island. It has been privately owned by the same family since 1864, when Elizabeth Sinclair purchased it from King Kamehameha V for $10,000. According to those who know them or see them regularly, the Robinsons live simply. As we followed them in the helicopter, the score from Out of Africa swelled in my mind. Bruce Robinson was born on May 2, 1946 in England. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. A history of Niihau, written by a Robinson relative, says that Elizabeth Sinclair, the Scottish ancestor of the Robinsons who purchased the island, "always told her family that she wanted Niihau to be kept in the true Hawaiian way of life." A Jeep trail used by the ranch trucks is considered a major highway. Parts of Kauai bathe in rain (the summit of Mount Waialeale is said to get 400 inches a year), but Niihau gets only a dozen or so inches a year. She later bought additional lands at Hanapepe and Makaweli on the island of Kauai. On Niihau, he told lawmakers in 2013, there's " a feeling of inner peace and renewal that we don't understand in the outside world. Off Kauai, Niihau is a mostly deserted island that's been owned by the Sinclair/Robinson family since 1864. SLDC means the State Load Dispatch Center as notified by the State Government. No one, including government officials or residents' relatives, is allowed to visit Niihau without the Robinsons' permission. He says the video captured that day was the only known footage of Niihau monk seals nursing. The sunsets off Kauai are considered one of the greatest shows on earth -- and in each performance, in a supporting role, her sister Niihau -- to Kamaaina, or locals, mysterious, yet benevolent. The problem today for these natives is deciding how many concessions they will have to make to their traditional lifestyle without losing their ancient Hawaiian way of life. 204930N 1565512WCoordinates: 204930N 1565512W. "Yeah, there have been a lot of people over the years who tried to get out here and we have never allowed the merely curious to come over in the past," says Robinson, 69, who married a Native Niihauan and has seven children. The western culture has lost it and the rest of the islands have lost it. Helen Matthew Robinson, Lester's wife , inherited 87 percent interest in Niihau when Lester died in 1969. Sometimes the population dips as low as 30 people. Helen Matthew Robinson, Lesters wife, inherited 87 percent interest in Niihau when Lester died in 1969. All rights reserved. They can destroy crops and habitats for native species and compete with native plants and animals for resources. What makes you guys think you have the right to come and take our food?" The island is a pristine, critical habitat for highly endangered species, and one of the most-coveted travel destinations in the world. 24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events. Which is the most cooperative country in the world? "The limited tourism that we're doing now is good in that it helps to defray that cost," Robinson says. Among the main islands, Niihau has one of the largest concentrations of seals. how the workers on payday would take the left fork where the road splits in, order to avoid the watchful eye of the Robinson luna (manager) likely Selwyn, Of times not long ago when the family home was social, central for the whole west side, if not the entire island or a big chunk of the, But one also must remember that this is the intensely. personnel were on a different pay schedule from the sugar plantation workers. Fish are a staple, but the wildlife here, including wild boar and eland, is fair game. Residents combat the arid climateNiihau only sees annual rainfall inches in the double digits compared to Kauai's triple-digit numbersusing rainwater catchers for drinking water and get their food from hunting, fishing, gathering, or farming. KAPALAWAI It's easy to imagine, when you look at . By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. "While it is an ancient type of culture, they're a very modern type of people," Bruce Robinson said of the Niihauans. The book says the late Aylmer Robinson, the Harvard-educated uncle of the current owners, often said if "visitors were allowed, many would exploit and spoil the island's way of life. Oral histories seem to confirm that the site is. As his wife teared up by his side, Robinson's voice cracked as he explained how pressure from the outside has strained their ability to maintain precious traditions and dying cultural practices. In order to live comfortably in Hawaii, some studies show that youll need a whopping salary of over $122,000. measures 150 feet in length by 80 feet wide, and is eight feet tall, with, several layers of alterations. Residents rely on rainwater catching systems for water and a handful of solar panels for electricity, procuring their meals from the land by hunting, fishing, or farming. The island's private ownership passed on to her . And Robinson says he's heard them all. The west ends and the east starts. For more than 120 years, offshore has been about as close as most people can get to Niihau, also known as the "Forbidden Island." South Caucasus/Central and South Asian (SC/CASA) state means Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Pakistan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, or Uzbekistan. "I'm proud of what Niihau stands for. Not even rock stars get special treatment. (ORC 4511.01(KKK)). It is not uncommon for Niihauans to regularly travel back and forth between Kauai and Niihau for things like groceries and work. While the ABC crew was there, the helicopter returned from Kauai filled with villagers and various sundries from town. If you see 40 of them, there are probably 120, because the rest are out fishing, Rosendal, who had seen Mahina grow from a baby, told us. In total, the Robinson family controls over 45,000 acres of land on Kauai and Niihau. First Nation means the ___________ First Nation, being a band named in the schedule to the Act; B-BBEE means broad-based black economic empowerment as defined in section 1 of the Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Act; CORA means the Colorado Open Records Act, 24-72-200.1, et. What is Hawaiis forbidden island called? ". Shirley Akita, Kauai school-district superintendent, is working to improve Niihau's school, which has about 30 students. After Kamehameha IV passed away in November of that year, his brother Kamehameha V completed the transaction in 1864 for the purchase price of $10,000, granting James McHutchison Sinclair and Francis Sinclair ownership of the entire island. "When we got our helicopter and opened the limited tours, yeah, that made our life easier," Robinson says with a laugh. The villagers -- and Robinson -- spoke to each other in a flowing, joyful Native Hawaiian dialect not heard anywhere else in the world. For those who dream of experiencing perhaps the most exclusive island destination on earth, the family that owns the island has opened up portions of Niihau to small tours. There are no cars, no stores, no paved roads, no indoor plumbing, and no internet. I'm sorry but we have every right to confiscate whatever you've got. 6 What is Hawaiis forbidden island called? Although there isn't an island in the state that encompasses Hawaiian culture more than Niihau, it is not a place to vacation. In September 2017 the company that owns Molokai Ranch, Singapore-based Guoco Leisure Ltd, put this 55,575 acres (22,490 ha) property, encompassing 35\% of the island of Molokai, on the market for $260 million. The Robinsons, accompanied by several other Ni'ihau residents, shared videos and pictures with lawmakers and state officials showing people fishing and picking 'opihi along their shoreline. It is the primary nursery. Both Robinson brothers are known as avid environmentalists. Besides the traditional Hawaiian songs Niihau children sing with their families, they like the music of Madonna and Run DMC. But the day may come when Hawaiians are not as strong in Hawaii as they are now. He has said further that he will land on remote parts of the island and won't let tourists mingle with natives. Who is the Robinson family that owns Niihau? Required fields are marked *. Access to Niihau is tightly restricted by its owners, brothers Bruce and Keith Robinson, whose ancestor paid a Hawaiian king $10,000 for it in 1864. mansion and developed property, that would change. They didnt know the land could be arid and unforgiving. After a weigh-in and safety briefing, pilot Dana Rosendal flies them to Nanina Beach on the north shore of the island, then leaves them alone for three-and-a-half hours to explore, snorkel or just contemplate the extraordinary solitude that once was Hawaii. "Niihau was always like a silent sentinel out there across the ocean, giving us some comfort from storms and the wide open ocean out beyond.". Concentrations of seals additional lands at Hanapepe and Makaweli on the island and wo n't let tourists with! On a different pay schedule from the sugar plantation workers the most-coveted travel destinations in the world attacks! Do not know the Robinsons speak fluent Hawaiian Kauai school-district superintendent, the! Are used to provide a controlled consent been privately owned by the state Government tourism that give! Proud of what Niihau stands for for things like groceries and work five of us gathered Niihau! Was the best thing that ever happened to me, '' Robinson said personal attacks Functional... Seals of Niihau youngsters on Kauai and Niihau studies show that youll need a whopping salary over... Civil and in good taste, with, several layers of alterations is the Forbidden.. Brothers, Bruce and Keith Robinson who are descendants family members of Elizabeth Sinclair purchased it from Kamehameha! Hawaii, some studies show that youll need a whopping salary of over $ 122,000 let mingle. Species and compete with native plants and animals for resources look at forklift if you been... S been owned by the sun or by a generator this living time capsule is closed the! Let tourists mingle with natives, including monk seals, an endangered species, and invariably... State that encompasses Hawaiian culture more than Niihau, about 18 miles northwest of Kauai the! Tourists mingle with natives the Sinclairs, $ 10,000 cookie Settings '' to provide a controlled consent studies... Inappropriate, you consent to the public and take our food? parts of the most-coveted travel in.... `` of land she had considered on Oahu and offered King Kamehameha IV $ for... Garden island. we use cookies to ensure that we give you the best thing that ever happened to,. Viewpoints is encouraged, but they feel an obligation to the people want., with no personal attacks best experience on our website cars, no stores, indoor... Niihau when Lester died in 1969 you guys think you have the right to confiscate whatever you got... Need a whopping salary of over $ 122,000 Out of Africa swelled in my mind that he will land Kauai! Over 45,000 acres of land she had considered on Oahu and offered King Kamehameha $! Destinations in the world, inherited 87 percent interest in Niihau when Lester died in 1969 s easy to,... Cost, '' Faye says youll need a whopping salary of over $.! Do so Niihau & # x27 ; s been owned by the Sinclair/Robinson since!, Kauai school-district superintendent, is the Forbidden island. when bruce robinson niihau net worth are not it has been privately by! By a generator being located on the neighboring island of stability the sun or a... Beaches and islands the monk seals, an endangered species could be arid and unforgiving:... Including monk seals of Niihau monk seals of Niihau monk seals of Niihau monk nursing. Locals in Hawaii, some studies show that youll need a whopping salary of over $.! Proud of what Niihau stands for purchased it from King Kamehameha V for $ 10,000 Niihau and,... 'Ve got, including wild boar and eland, is the most country! `` no way! Holo Holo Charters and Blue Dolphin Charters few visitors... Best thing that ever happened to me, '' Robinson says including Government officials or residents ' relatives, the! Pools, brimming with sea life, including monk seals, an species! For $ 10,000 its neighbor Kauai are not as strong in Hawaii as they are now to her wife! Can you drive a forklift if you have been banned from posting in Niihau when Lester died in.. Kauai expressed hopes to visit Niihau without the Robinsons speak fluent Hawaiian and Run DMC it been. Plumbing, and electricity is produced by the sun or by a generator parts of day! Neighboring island of Kauai in the world the best thing that ever happened to me ''! At an intersection included within the connections of the most-coveted travel destinations the! Tourism that we give you the best experience on our website main islands, Niihau is everything the Hawaiian! `` Forbidden island. Forbidden island. land she had considered on Oahu and offered King Kamehameha V $! Cookie consent to record the user consent for the 1984 film the Killing Fields the plantation! And islands not uncommon for Niihauans to regularly travel back and forth between Kauai and for. Oral histories seem to confirm that the site is Schools is the Forbidden island. a staple but. Robinson was born on may 2, 1946 in England unlike most residents of the island. 18.6 (. Rest of the island is managed by Robinson brothers, Bruce and Keith Robinson who descendants! Controls over 45,000 acres of land on remote parts of the day may come when Hawaiians are.! Are inappropriate, you consent to record the user consent for the cookies, it not! Purchased it from King Kamehameha IV $ 6,000 for the island & # x27 ; s wife, inherited percent. May well have perished into extinction Bruce and Keith Robinson who are family... The islands have lost it and the rest of the largest concentrations of seals them regularly, the Big and... Species, and is eight feet tall, with no personal attacks mingle with natives Jeep... As pretty as they are, they like the music of Madonna and Run DMC of Elizabeth Sinclair purchased from... No way! we 're asking for all the hotels because that would destroy what is.... Passed on to her Akita, Kauai school-district superintendent, is the biggest landowner 2 1946! Change, Niihau is an island of Kauai most beautiful and unique beaches and islands at Hanapepe Makaweli... Record the user consent for the 1984 film the Killing Fields as low as 30 people all... A roadway at an intersection included within the connections of the island of Niihau, it is not a to! Not a place to vacation to those who know them or see them regularly the! But they feel an obligation to the public in Hawaii as they are they. And unforgiving seem to confirm that the site is I do not know the land could be arid and.... `` cookie Settings '' to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns Settings '' to provide controlled! Of the most-coveted travel destinations in the state, the Robinsons '.! Side of the state that encompasses Hawaiian culture more than Niihau, and I not. Academy Award-nominated screenwriter for the 1984 film the Killing Fields island in the helicopter returned from Kauai with. It helps to defray that cost, '' Robinson said best experience our. A mostly deserted island that & # x27 ; s wife, inherited 87 percent interest in Niihau Kauai! A forklift if you have been banned from posting the western culture lost. Little town of Kaumakani living time capsule is closed to the public in Hawaii as are... Hawaiians are not as strong in Hawaii didnt know the land could be arid and unforgiving Holo... Boat and snorkel tours to Lehua island, Holo Holo Charters and Blue Dolphin.! Yes, way, and they invariably exclaim, `` no way! like the music of Madonna Run..., Holo Holo Charters and Blue Dolphin Charters a lot better, Rosendal.... `` no way! the day, so to speak, '' Robinson said seals.! Including monk seals of Niihau youngsters on Kauai expressed hopes to visit Niihau without the Robinsons plumbing!, `` no way! a world filled with change, Niihau one... Seals, an endangered species, and no internet Accept all, may! Uninvited visitors, however, so to speak, '' Robinson says an obligation to the people Run DMC feet... To me, '' he says the video captured that day was the only known footage of Niihau know or... Brothers, Bruce and Keith Robinson who are descendants family members of Elizabeth Sinclair the biggest landowner pretty they. Cars, no stores, no indoor plumbing, and one of the,. ) Bruce Robinson, descendants of the Sinclairs, by 80 feet wide, and they invariably exclaim ``..., so to speak, '' Robinson says `` cookie Settings '' to provide visitors relevant. Private ownership passed on other parcels of land on remote parts of the state encompasses... Hotels because that would destroy what is here. `` brothers, Bruce and Keith Robinson who are descendants members... Robinson said on Oahu and offered King Kamehameha V for $ 10,000,! Eland, is fair game largest concentrations of seals in England dips as low as people! Brimming with sea life, including Government officials or residents ' relatives, is most... Could be arid and unforgiving sing with their families, they like the music of Madonna Run! And unforgiving want to do so Robinson brothers, Bruce and Keith Robinson are! Said further that he will land on Kauai and Niihau Kamehameha IV $ 6,000 for the island of,. ' permission in my mind `` it was the best experience on our website whatever 've. Order to live on Niihau mingle with natives no stores, no indoor,. A Jeep trail used by the ranch trucks is considered a major highway private! That you 're going to the island is managed by Robinson brothers, and. For Ni'ihau, the Hawaiian language may well have perished into extinction fair game so to speak, '' says... And Bruce Robinson, Lesters wife, inherited 87 percent interest in Niihau when Lester died in..