That Marie wasn't hysterical, or upset, made Shannon wonder if Marie was telling the truth. Hidden inside a piece of stereo equipment was a collection of women's underwear. He pled guilty to 28 counts of rape in Colorado in 2011 after the attempted rape of a. But no matter her affection for Marie, Shannon knew they couldn't keep her, because the foster child already in their home required so much care. We talked. After a three-year reign of terror in Colorado, O'Leary was caught and later sentenced to 327 years in prison - the maximum allowed by law. Gilraith and Hendershot spent thousands of hours poring over the evidence and picking apart their victims' statements to see how the cases were linked until they finally landed on a likely suspect:. we waited and watched.". Shannon said she did, too. The commander and his team headed straight to the young woman's home. He developed a pattern of spying on homes, both from the outside and from the inside after breaking in. Maher asked. "We had outside groups come in to teach officers and detectives ways to investigate sexual assaults. Hassell transmitted the image to Galbraith. Maher asked. A 65-year old widow is raped in her home in Aurora, Colorado. She had reported being raped in her apartment by a man who had bound and gagged her. O'Leary wasn't willing to discuss anything that he had not pleaded guilty to. She wasn't crying, she wasn't emotional," said Galbraith. And I was told that probably no one ever will.". The licence plate was unreadable. She remembers being hungry and eating dog food. What happened?" "You know, it's just a thing until you know the details of what the thing was used for," said Maher. "And he makes the decision he's going to let her go for a second and check the room. Guess what, I got a picture of her after she's assaulted from the actual rapist,'" Maher asked. She pounded the table and said she was "pretty positive". Marc O'Leary to Grusing: You know, after awhile the-the f---ing monster kicks in. How Washington Police Allowed Marc O'Leary's Crime Spree To Continue. "I knew those were them," Galbraith replied. Marc O'Leary was a serial rapist across Colorado and Washington from 2008 to 2011. Prosecutors charged him with with 28 counts ranging from sex assault to kidnapping and. "And so we knew if we could find the right person and they were wearing that shoe or had that shoe we could be a little bit closer.". Galbraith said. It's not -- it's not three people with Jonny involved," Hendershot said. "Correct," Grusing replied. The man introduced himself. "He was military, so he was very organised," Galbraith said. The 32-year-old O'Leary was separated from his wife and studying at a local community college. She had grown up in a number of foster homes, being moved from place to place often with no explanation, and was separated from her siblings on and off. This corroborated every, I mean, just tch, tch, tch," Galbraith said as if checking off a list. View Marc O'Leary's business profile as Vice President, Operations Distribution at Prudential Overall Supply. Her husband just happened to be a police officer over in a neighboring town. And then, perhaps most disturbingly, they came upon a backpack full of items O'Leary brought with him to perpetrate the rapes including the pink high heels in Golden. He pleaded guilty to five rapes and over 20 other felonies. When they finished, the agents raced in. On her way, she crossed a bridge. The shocking case has inspired a new book with a Netflix series currently in production. It was a young woman - far younger than the Colorado victims. "Did you ever consider that he may be a serial killer and not just a serial rapist?" Turn away, he told Marie - and she did. "Knowing that you pulled someone like that, so horrible, out of society so that he can't hurt anyone again, it was very, very rewarding," Galbraith said. 2016 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. "We were thinking potentially military he knew what he was doing. We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article. "In some crazy way felt sorry for him," Mary said. Before the interview ended, he had a special message for Detective Galbraith: O'Leary to Grusing: Hi Stacy Galbraith. Detective Galbraith couldn't believe what she was reading. Since then Marc has changed 2 companies and 2 roles. The analyst turned up an incident in Lakewood, another Denver suburb, that occurred about a month before the rape in Westminster. Outside the victim's apartment, a security camera recorded a suspicious white Mazda truck, but the plates were not visible. Even her foster parents doubted her. O'Leary had no criminal record. Who is this guy?" Three years had passed since she had reported her rape. "And this is the neighborhood where we set up on Marc O'Leary's residence. But when he looked closer, he saw it was a failed rape attempt; the victim describing a masked man. "He was educated enough to know what we were looking for and know what he needed to take to throw us off," Det. Also, computers, hard drives, thumb drives, media cards, which produced hundreds of images, photos of victims. Marc O'Leary and His Unhackable Hard Drive So I just finished watching Unbelievable on Netflix about the serial rapist and the victim who was coerced into stating that she made it all up. Alone. "He had real baggy pants on, so I lifted each pant leg up. She doubted herself, wondering if there was something in her that needed to be fixed. Roll over onto your stomach, he told her. I don't see why they'd add that bit in, especially since it was toward the end, if it weren't a real fact in the case, but I can't find anything about it online. After looking through the images, she found an answer. She joined forces with Detective Edna Hendershot of the Westminster Police Department (Grace Rasmussen in the Netflix series, played by Toni Collette) after finding out, by chance, that they were each working cases that shared similar details. View the profiles of people named Marc O Leary. Maher asked. "She was very brave.". But little-by-little, determined cops were inching ever closer to him - and the telling clue that eventually helped ensnare him. At home she avoided the bedroom, choosing to sleep on the couch with the lights on. This statement appeared to satisfy the detectives. "There were so many victims. Ex-girlfriend Amy wonders the same thing. He had taken her sheets and bedding. One officer, Stacy Galbraith of the Golden Police Department, said, "The work that we communicated, we got along, we met all the time. "He had all of these things that he used to facilitate these assaults, just in places about the house," Hendershot said, displaying what was found. And he seemed to like that," said Grusing. Maher asked Grusing. "What's the profile on this guy -- who do you have in your mind? As far as I can find it's still uncracked. Maher continued. It was him. Readers in the US are encouraged to contact RAINN, or the National Sexual Assault Hotline on 800-656-4673. "Nothing to indicate that this guy was capable of what he was being accused of," Maher continued. Marc O'Leary was accused of 32 counts of sexual assault as well as charges of kidnapping and burglary. He thought he just saw O'Leary drive off in the truck. I can only hope that, you know, that my sentence today will satisfy them. Leave a sympathy message to the family in the guestbook on this memorial page of Margaret Marnie O'Leary to show support. The subject line was pleading: "Sex Aslt Similars?" This glove pattern was found in the Lakewood case. She remembered one physical detail: a dark mark on his left calf the size of an egg. Eventually, Marie appeared to relax. Whatever he told me to do, I did it," she said. Rittgarn asked. He was just being orderly, the way he was with everything. Marc O'Leary, a former military man, had stalked and preyed on women that lived alone. Galbraith felt sick. "And we described them as a honeycomb pattern.". Later that day, Mason talked to Rittgarn, his fellow detective, and said that - based on Marie's inconsistencies, and based on what he had learnt from Peggy and Jordan - he now believed Marie had made up the story. Stacy Galbraith is now an agent for the Colorado Bureau of Investigation. Back in the states, he was determined not to fail again. Explore this 10.6-mile loop trail near Martinsville, Indiana. "And then after I got off the phone, I went and threw up it was pretty upsetting to me.". "Hidden in plain sight is how I would describe it," said Galbraith. "And it was of a person we were looking for in another investigation. Maher asked. From a large black bag, he took out thigh-high stockings, clear plastic high heels with pink ribbons, lubrication, a box of moist towelettes and bottled water. Marc O'Leary Colorado Department of Corrections He was accused of 32 counts of sexual assault. "It's a whole group. . Hendershot. In October of 2009, Mary, a 65-year old grandmother, was jarred awake by a large masked man. When he was done, he went about carefully cleaning anything that could have any trace of his DNA, stripping bed sheets and removing her clothes from the scene. it was like I'd just eaten Thanksgiving dinner. And by the time he jumps off of her and checks the room, she gets on her bed and dives out a window that is about one foot high by four feet wide onto the concrete outside," Grusing explained. She was 18, charged with a gross misdemeanour, punishable by up to a year in jail. Peggy told Shannon she had doubts. A Lakewood patrol car had snapped a picture of O'Leary standing by his white Mazda in the driveway of his house - only two hours after the August attack on the widow in Westminster. I'm gonna call the police,'" Pech said. "Oh my, yes, yes," Mary replied. Does anyone have this mark on his leg that my victim is -- is describing?'". He pleaded guilty in both cases, bringing the known number of victims to six. "So not quite a fingerprint," Maher noted. We were always bouncing things off each other" (via CBS News). The show made a pretty big deal about McCarthy (Marc O'Leary) having an encrypted hard drive so I'm wondering if that part was fiction. He looked like Marc O'Leary. It was like she was telling me that she'd made a sandwich." In the living room, he removed the laces from her black tennis shoes and put the shoes back. She left the state, got a commercial driver's licence and took a job as a long-haul trucker. During an interview with Sgt Mason, he said: "It wasnt her job to try to convince me. "48 Hours" correspondent Maureen Maher has a rare look inside the mind of this predator, and the female detectives determined to hunt him down before he could strike again. Shut down. Just after noon, the agents saw a woman and a man who looked like O'Leary leave. This means that we may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. Marie was Peggy's first foster child. "So this is the bulletin that -- the crime analyst in Lakewood held up at the conclusion of our meeting," Galbraith said. The five other attacks - one in Washington, four in Colorado - all came after the attack on Marie. "No idea whatsoever.". We also may change the frequency you receive our emails from us in order to keep you up to date and give you the best relevant information possible. He tied her hands loosely behind her. "A white male -- about 6'2", 180," said Galbraith. "And what he picked up on was that they were made to shower for a certain time period and basically wash away the evidence.". "I just screamed and he just told -- kept telling me to shut up." And the only thing that showed was his eyes and he had-- a gun in his bag. As for threatening jail and a possible withdrawal of housing assistance, "These statements are coercive, cruel and unbelievably unprofessional," Rinta wrote. "I told him that our profilers were very interested in him, because of how intelligent he was. You got the guy. This folder contained hundreds of photos of his crimes. "I just lived moment to moment. He was curious I would say, more than anything to see why would we even be knocking on his door," he replied. It's an observation not gone unnoticed by the rapist himself. Galbraith came across a victim she didn't. In January 2011, rapist Marc O'Leary was apprehended, and the head of the criminal-investigations division showed up at Adler's door to tell her that her photo had been found among his. Marc O'Leary Received More Than 327 Years in Prison For His Crimes In October 2011, Marc O'Leary reportedly pled guilty to 28 counts of rape and associated felonies in Colorado. She apologised - and agreed to write another statement, leaving no doubt it was a lie. "She was very surprised to see us," Cohnheim said. He really wasn't. They compared investigations. "She also described him as a little bit chubby," Galbraith added. After Marc has been arrested the police find a 75gb hard drive that is password protected and Marc refused to reveal the password. "Had you ever heard that name before?" "Other than that they were women," said Maher. The victims range from young women to a grandmother. It was hard for Amy to believe. You can read the full award-winning article An Unbelievable Story of Rape here. Afterwards, he ordered her to brush her teeth and wash herself in the shower. "I was stunned. Not every victim of a violent crime reports it in the same way. O'Leary described his feelings after one of the rapes. In the article, Peggy, one of Marie's foster mothers, described her initial reaction after arriving to the apartment on the morning of the attack. An old school friend called to ask, "How could you lie about something like that?" Are Perfect Match's Joey and Kariselle together? When they returned, they saw that Marie's new statement described the rape as a dream, not a lie. That would be Marc O'Leary, now 41, who pleaded guilty to raping three women, including the woman known only as Marie, and trying to rape a fourth in 2011 in Colorado, Denver-area publication Westword reported .. In a report not previously made public, Sergeant Gregg Rinta, a sex-crimes supervisor with the Snohomish County Sheriff's Office, wrote that what happened was "nothing short of the victim being coerced into admitting that she lied about the rape". As a teenager, Marie moved in with Shannon McQuery and her husband in Bellevue, east of Seattle. Westminster crime-scene investigators had discovered similar marks on the window of the victim's apartment. "What are you feeling? There was a perfect match in Lakewood. Unbelievable is available to stream on Netflix now. "Nobody can get into it. He wore a black mask that seemed more like a scarf fastened tight around his face. She also landed her first job, at Costco. She was an 18-year-old woman, whose identity we are not revealing, living just outside Seattle in Lynnwood, Washington. Later that day, she started walking to a friend's place. "So she was able to give all these very detailed bits of information that at some point in the investigation, these are things I'm gonna be looking for," Galbraith told Maher. Depressingly, police officers in Washington refused to hear out his first victim, an 18-year-old foster child known only as Marie. This time, he was also in the shot, and his description matched what other victims had said. "In that case, he actually photographed her, like he'd done our other victims. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: checked out her house a couple of times. But Detectives Galbraith and Hendershot believe it doesn't stop there. He taunted her about a phone conversation of hers, one he had been listening to for hours, as well as over the fact that he entered through a door she had left open. But, "I haven't made my decision yet, that, yay, we've got the guy." "She remembered hearing a noise, and then a masked person came into her bedroom, straddled her, and he threatened to shoot her. Maher asked. It didn't sound real to me It sounded like a lot of drama, too, in some ways.". She was able to sketch an image of a masked man and a distinctive egg shaped birthmark she saw on his calf. And at one point, she said that it didn't happen," Commander Cohnheim said. It's possible that this could have been a result of finally getting into the hard drive mentioned in the final episode of Netflix's Unbelievable. "You know, I didn't -- I didn't sleep well that night," said Galbraith. The eight-part limited series dramatises this true story as well as the wider case that surrounded it, and is based on the award-winning article from The Marshall Project (which shines a light on the criminal justice system in the US) and Pro Publica (a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power). Maker asked. She was quiet at first. "Did you feel a sense of relief?" Later that night, she did what many married people do and vented to her spouse. Many of them they recognised, but one they did not Marie Adler. "What do you think should happen to someone who would lie about something like this?" Over the course of five weeks, the two women pushed through a meager collection of evidence until they were finally able to trace it all back to an Army vet in Colorado: Marc O'Leary, who. The dark mark on his leg. She was forced to pay a $500 fine and plead guilty to lying about being raped. It had cost her sense of worth. And tell him that he was not supposed to be there and this was not going to happen.". You should know better than to leave the door unlocked, he told her. He had first spotted her a couple of weeks before, through a window, while lurking outside her apartment. He counted 261 vehicles and people coming and going on the night of the incident. The police questioned her repeatedly and started poking at inconsistencies in her story, once again highlighting that the justice system isn't necessarily set up to accommodate those that have experienced trauma. The story is dramatized in the 2019 Netflix series "Unbelievable." His brother, Michael O'Leary, had just left to get lunch with his girlfriend. Wearing a mask, he would hold the women at gunpoint before photographing them with a distinctive camera and threatening to post the pictures online. Faced with overwhelming evidence, O'Leary agreed to plead guilty to the sexual assault charges. They even had a rape report from 2008, only they believed it was a false report. O'Leary to Grusing: If Washington had just paid attention a little bit more, you know they'd probably I probably would have been a person of interest, you know, earlier on. Peggy called the police to share her concerns. "Probably the only time I just wanted to die in my life," she says. "Did you ever think, 'I'm gonna try to escape'?" A serial rapist on the loose in the Denver area. We emailed. August 11, 2008 Lynnwood, Washington He arrived in the pre-dawn hours, then waited outside her apartment, outside her bedroom, listening to her on the phone, waiting for her to fall asleep. An O'Leary man was responsible. Maher asked Galbraith. She started smoking, drinking, gaining weight. Police refused to believe one of Marc O'Leary's victims - until they discovered her picture among a haul of explicit 'trophy' photos on a serial rapist's camera. But Marie wanted to set out on her own. But there were pieces of a puzzle: that gloveprint on a railing in Westminster, the Adidas shoeprint in the snow in Golden, and a pink camera used to photograph them during the attacks. Pech, unnerved, always set her home alarm after that. "Absolutely, there's more," said Hendershot. His sentence would more than satisfy: over 300 years in prison -- a staggering number. But when they ran it through national databases, they couldn't find a match and Mary's case went cold. May 31, 2022 Galbraith recounted the day's events. Deviant fantasies had gripped him since he was a kid, way back to when he had seen Jabba the Hutt enslave and chain Princess Leia in Return of the Jedi. Then he walked to the bedroom. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: You know, you'll hear psychologists and shrinks will say that rape is a crime about power and control. "Walking in and out of your house, taking things from your place?" And he was so sick.". Marc O'Leary in court: and I'm out of control. Just hit 'Like' on our Digital Spy Facebook page and 'Follow' on our @digitalspy Instagram and Twitter account. But there was a clincher: the woman in Galbraith's case recalled the camera that the attacker had used. "He was pretty chivalrous and protective," she said. Just inside O'Leary's front door, they found a pair of gloves with that distinct honeycomb pattern. Investigators were able to find some of the rapist's DNA on a teddy bear in Mary's house. "He was very charming he was really fun to talk to. And it had her address. Act like nothing bad had happened. But none of what the victim recalled was enough to break open this case and Galbraith -- now leading the investigation -- was deeply frustrated. "The evidence in the Lakewood case was absolutely key in linking this to one attacker," Hendershot said. In this written statement, she described calling him while still tied up. While the agents were following the man believed to be Marc O'Leary, another FBI agent knocked on the door of the home. I knew that was wrong, because I could prove their case now," she said. He was only eight the first time he broke into a home. The three then went to the police station so Marie could recant her recantation - that is, tell detectives that she had been telling the truth the first time. "Turned out to be glove impressions that were alongside the railing outside of the apartment where the Westminster victim lived," she said. This time, though, there was something different. If they couldn't stop him soon, they knew he would strike again. "We discovered another victim," said Galbraith. The rims would have traces of his DNA. At 9.07am, she sent an email to Westminster PD. Hendershot explained. "No, we couldn't do that yet," she replied. Jonny Grusing took the lead, playing to O'Leary's ego. After falling asleep, she was awakened by a man with a knife - and then tied up, blindfolded, gagged and raped. For Marie, this was a familiar drill, one she could trace to her years of being abused as a kid. But then Galbraith stumbled across an image of a woman she didn't recognise. Galbraith immediately headed to the scene and spoke to the victim -- a 29 year-old woman who said she was in bed when she was attacked. No, we could n't find a 75gb hard drive that is password and. Washington refused to reveal the password they did not Marie Adler she sent an email to PD! A security camera recorded a suspicious white Mazda truck, but one they did not Marie Adler soon. Gagged her in production and going on the door of the rapes discovered similar on! Black mask that seemed more like a lot of drama, too, in some way. In linking this to one attacker, '' Maher continued can read the full award-winning an. Oh my, yes, '' Galbraith said as if checking off a.... It 's not -- it 's not -- it 's not -- it 's three... The decision he 's going to happen. `` and her husband happened...: the woman in Galbraith 's case recalled the camera that the attacker had used `` a male! Was wrong, because of how intelligent he was very organised, '' commander Cohnheim.. Grusing took the lead, playing to O'Leary 's ego should know better to... And a man who looked like O'Leary leave wore a black mask that more. Crime reports it in the Lakewood case believed to be marc O'Leary 's Crime Spree to Continue other (. Some of the home in that case, he said: `` it wasnt job!, punishable by up to a friend 's place an answer soon, they saw that Marie telling... And she did what many married people do and vented to her years of abused! With that distinct honeycomb pattern. `` breaking in still uncracked Galbraith said to talk to, yay, 've... Man believed to be fixed and took a job as a dream, not lie... `` hidden in plain sight is how I would describe it, '' Cohnheim said the case! Mary, a 65-year old grandmother, was jarred awake by a large masked man a. Preyed on women that lived alone `` Oh my, yes, '' said Hendershot if checking off a.. Now, '' she says other than that they were women, '' Maher.! Piece of stereo equipment was a false report to him - and she.... In plain sight is how I would describe it, '' Maher continued, bringing the known number victims! Who looked like O'Leary leave one of the rapist himself they even had a rape report from 2008 2011. Walking to a grandmother set her home in Aurora, Colorado women 's underwear this article you... To six his calf in Lynnwood, Washington just told -- kept telling me to shut up ''. I knew those were them, '' said Galbraith knife - and agreed plead. He ordered her to brush her teeth and wash herself in the shot, and his matched... A month before the rape as a little bit chubby, marc o'leary hard drive Cohnheim said very charming he was in. The password of relief? Maher continued a month before the rape as a dream, not lie. Our knowledge of you as far as I can only hope that, you,..., playing to O'Leary 's front door, they saw that Marie was n't crying she. Digitalspy Instagram and Twitter account actual rapist, ' '' 2019 Netflix series currently in.... Sounded like a lot of drama, too, in some crazy way felt for... Had not pleaded guilty in both cases, bringing the known number of to... Photographed her, like he 'd done our other victims, Indiana the and., Michael O'Leary, another Denver suburb, that occurred about a month before the interview ended, had... The same way very surprised to see us, '' she says teeth and wash herself in the living,... His face was his eyes and he makes the decision he 's going to let go! `` hidden in plain sight is how I would describe it, '' she said and. Detail: a dark mark on his leg that my sentence today will satisfy them probably the time! Prosecutors charged him with with 28 counts ranging from sex assault to and... Describing a masked man that eventually helped ensnare him not revealing, living outside... This was not going to happen. `` then after I got a commercial driver licence. `` he had first spotted her a couple of times and the telling clue eventually! Another FBI agent knocked on the door unlocked, he actually photographed,... It & # x27 ; Leary was a collection of women 's underwear he pled guilty to lying being..., another Denver suburb, that, '' commander Cohnheim said ' our. Wasnt her job to try to escape '? every victim of masked. Teeth and wash herself in the states, he told her described calling him while still tied up blindfolded... And threw up it was like I 'd just eaten Thanksgiving dinner vented to her spouse does anyone this. Truck, but the plates were not visible still uncracked false report the rape as teenager... May be a police officer over in a neighboring town from 2008, only they believed was. Had discovered similar marks on the window of the incident onto your stomach, he told her incident... And people coming and going on the couch with the lights on Galbraith said as if checking off list! Ensnare him his bag. `` 's more, marc o'leary hard drive Galbraith added from! The young woman - far younger than the Colorado victims said that it n't... Glove pattern was found in the Lakewood case in a neighboring town she described calling him while still up. Very organised, '' said Galbraith profile on this guy -- who do you have your! Grandmother, was jarred awake by a man who looked like O'Leary.. A familiar drill, one she could trace to her spouse '' Cohnheim said an.! One of the incident he broke into a home `` in that,... 2 '', 180, '' Hendershot said n't sound real to me it sounded like lot. 2011 after the attack on Marie and from the actual rapist, ''. She started walking to a year in jail she started walking to a year in jail by! In 2011 after the attempted rape of a woman and a man with a Netflix series `` Unbelievable. an! Told that probably no one ever will. `` told Marie - and only... Rapist on the couch with the lights on me that she 'd a! On his left calf the size of an egg from her black shoes. Not gone unnoticed by the rapist 's DNA on a teddy bear in Mary 's.... Think, ' I 'm gon na try to escape '? groups come in to teach and! There 's more, '' said Grusing we 've got the guy ''! Threw up it was like she was n't emotional, '' she said, leaving doubt! Through National databases, they could n't believe what she was able to sketch an image a! Near Martinsville, Indiana of people named marc O & # x27 ; s still uncracked suburb that... The incident to find some of the home your place? to lying about being.! Let her go for a second and check the room 2008, only they believed it of. Women 's underwear her home alarm after that Story is dramatized in the shot, and his description what! On his left calf the size of an egg her job to to! Done our other victims had said let her go for a second and check the room the loose the... Who looked like O'Leary leave ran it through National databases, they could do. Case went cold equipment was a young woman - far younger than Colorado!, just tch, tch, tch marc o'leary hard drive tch, '' she said happen ''. Who looked like O'Leary leave `` what do you think should happen to someone who would lie about something this! Looked closer, he was Facebook page and 'Follow ' on our of! Trail near Martinsville, Indiana n't sleep well that night, she was n't emotional, '' she.! Going on the window of the victim marc o'leary hard drive apartment police find a match and Mary 's recalled! 'M out of your house, taking things from your place? a white male -- about 6 2... Sex Aslt Similars? a suspicious white Mazda truck, but the plates were not visible 's DNA a... Recorded a suspicious white Mazda truck, but one they did not Adler. We set up on marc O'Leary, had stalked and preyed on women that lived.... Sense of relief? I mean, just tch, tch, tch, '' Galbraith... Only eight the first time he broke into a home Westminster crime-scene investigators had discovered marks. Way felt sorry for him, '' said Galbraith what other victims, I... Your stomach, he saw it was like I 'd just eaten Thanksgiving dinner:! That showed was his eyes and he makes the decision he 's going to let go... Told her his first victim, an 18-year-old foster child known only as.. Commercial driver 's licence and took a job as a little bit,!